Year-End Lists

But Here We Are

9. The 20 Best Albums of 2023: Mikael Wood: Los Angeles Times
13. The 50 Best Albums of 2023: Albumism
16. The Best Albums of 2023: NME
16. Top 40 Best Albums Of 2023: mxdwn
39. 50 Best Albums of 2023: Consequence
50. The 50 Best Albums of 2023: Yardbarker
54. Best Albums of 2023: Stephen Thomas Erlewine
64. Top 100 Albums of 2023: Under the Radar

• Our 50 Favorite Albums of 2023: Boston Globe
• 25 Best Rock + Metal Albums of 2023: Loudwire
• Top 50 Albums of 2023: Anthony Fantano: The Needle Drop

Medicine at Midnight

6. Top 40 Rock Albums of 2021: Ultimate Classic Rock
39. The 100 Best Albums of 2021: Albumism
40. 50 Best Albums of 2021: Rolling Stone

• The Best Albums of 2021: Craig Jenkins: New York: Vulture
• Best of 2021: AllMusic

Concrete and Gold

27. 50 Best Albums of 2017: NME
42. 50 Best Albums of 2017: Mojo
49. 51 Best Albums of 2017: Rolling Stone

Sonic Highways

12. 50 Best Albums of 2014: Rolling Stone

Wasting Light

1. Top 50 Albums of 2011: Guitar World
1. 20 Best Albums of 2011: Antiquiet
5. Top 50 Albums of 2011: Consequence
6. 10 Best Albums of 2011: Rip It Up
8. Top Albums of 2011: Sarah Rodman: Boston Globe
11. Top 50 Albums of 2011: Gigwise
12. Top Albums of 2011: Thomas Conner: Chicago Sun-Times
17. Top 20 Albums of 2011: Filter
20. 50 Best Albums of 2011: Rolling Stone
41. 75 Best Albums of 2011: PopMatters
43. Best Albums of 2011: NME
46. 50 Best Albums of 2011: Spin
54. Top 100 Albums of 2011: Village Voice: Pazz & Jop
80. Top 100 Albums of the 2010s: Consequence

• Favorite Rock Albums of 2011: AllMusic