Lists
- Time: Annabel Gutterman: The 10 Best Fiction Books of 2023
- Autostraddle: Kayla Kumari Upadhyaya: The Top 12 Queer Novels of 2023
- Vulture: Maris Kreizman: The Best Books of 2023
- Esquire: The 20 Best Books of 2023
- PEN/Faulkner Award: Fiction 2024
- Los Angeles Times: Hillary Kelly: Five Best Novels of 2023
- Chicago Tribune: Christopher Borrelli: 10 Best Books for 2023
- Vanity Fair: Our 20 Favorite Books of 2023
- Powell's Books: Best Fiction of 2023
- New York Times: 100 Notable Books of 2023
- Electric Lit: Best Novels of 2023
- New Yorker: The Best Books of 2023
- Publishers Weekly: 10 Best Books of 2023
- Fresh Air: Maureen Corrigan: Top 10 Books of 2023